Breaking Dawn: Will Fans Still See the Twilight Movie?

by Avid Reader on August 6, 2008

in Avid Musings

Just pon­der­ing aloud if read­ers who were more than dis­sat­is­fied with the con­clu­sion of the Twi­light saga would still be inter­ested in the movie? The movie isn’t due out until the sec­ond week of Decem­ber. Maybe the pro­duc­ers will hope fans suf­fer from a short mem­ory spans. As for me — I will forego the film adap­ta­tion. The pub­lic­ity shots does not engen­der me to the project. I thought Twi­light was a great read but such is life, I’ve moved on to the next great thing. What­ever that is. Ha. Bet you were wait­ing for me to say what that next great thing was, too. Well, maybe not.

For Fur­ther Reading

Tagged as: Twilight Saga, Twilight: The Movie

{ 39 comments }

gracie January 25, 2009 at 2:41 pm

hay Cinda a big fan not really! if you see that co star Jacob you should not fire him because he is the best and i would offer a mil­lion dol­lars on him when i have it so good luck!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

coffee January 17, 2009 at 1:08 pm

i don’t under­stand what is the appeal of Robert Pat­tin­son (Edward), his nose looks funny

cheynna January 15, 2009 at 4:57 pm

i though that twi­light ws the best Edward is the hotest in the whole book but brak­ing dawn is the bets if u love twi­light u will love brak­ing down!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
LOVE CHEYANNA if u like brak­ing dawn u will like me call me nd we cn talk about brak­ing dawn for hours call at 931–456-9008

Chloza January 14, 2009 at 8:15 pm

I think that the main dis­ap­point­ment for me was that for quite a bit of the book, she geared us up for an epic fight. But in the end, it still fiz­zled out to a happy ending.

Only one peron (Irina) was actu­ally killed, and due to the fact we only really met her when she died, I had no real emo­tional out­fall when she died.

Then, of course, Renes­mee. Her name I can accept now — a unique name for a kind of unique baby, and also a hybrid name for a hybrid. Renee (human) and Esme (vam­pire), and Carlisle and Char­lie for her mid­dle name (Carlie).

I’ve already seen the movie, of course, and I hope that the next one is bet­ter. It was just a lit­tle too awk­ward for my lik­ing. Some parts I just wanted to hide my head and groan. But peo­ple should still see it. I think the only rea­son it has made so much is the huge fan­dom. I’m not sure if I’ll buy the DVD, or if I want to watch it again.

Abuse me all you like — that’s my opinion!

jessica January 14, 2009 at 5:58 pm

hey. i enjoyed all of the twi­light saga. My favorites were elipse and break­ing dawn, so i dont really know where all the crit­i­cism is com­ing from. I thought the movie was very well put together, but i would imag­ine that mak­ing a break­ing dawn movie would be tough. it was very detailed and out of the ordi­nary, never the less very good.

Rosalie January 13, 2009 at 4:55 pm

I’m audi­tion­ing for Irina or Jane. Noroc! to all fel­low auditioners!

Rosalie January 13, 2009 at 4:53 pm

I’m defi­nately try­ing out for either older Renes­mee, or one of the girl Vol­turi ppl. I was also thinkin of try­ing for Irina, but I’m still not sure. I swear, if they don’t hold audi­tions in Char­lotte, N.C, Imma gonna be sooo mad! I don’t wanna go aaaaaall the way to Cal­i­for­nia just to audi­tion. But…if I hafta, I will!

Tanya January 2, 2009 at 5:54 pm

OMG i loved twi­light it was such an amaz­ing film
and i really do wish that they do turn
eclipse and break­ing dawn into movies
cause break­ing dawn was my fav book
but thats just my oppin­ion but i will
defo be goin 2 see it !!!!!!!!!!!!!

Kristin December 8, 2008 at 7:47 am

i love Eclipse and I will Like break­ing dawn i really want them to be a into movie peo­ple said they will not but i really think u should make them a movie as well cus its not fin­shin the series soo it will be like thts the end of the movie series but new moon isnt due till next dec ember but still i really want them allt o be movies

michele December 5, 2008 at 9:03 am

i think that peo­ple should go see the movie and then read the book so it wont be disapointing

Hannah December 4, 2008 at 6:55 pm

um hi. i saw your com­ments on break­ing dawn so if the next per­son who com­ments could please tell me why break­ing dawn is so bad i would appre­ci­ate it. thx

Avid Reader December 2, 2008 at 8:53 am

Let’s keep it civil. I hope other read­ers will ignore com­ments that are rude or dis­re­spect­ful to oth­ers espe­cially those com­ments that do not add any­thing to the dis­cus­sion. Carry on.

Jennifer December 2, 2008 at 6:21 am

If any­one that hates the whole twi­light series shall be pun­ished and will go to hell. I LOVE TWILIGHT SO SO SO SO SO SO SO… MUCH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i read all the books and wanna see all the movies rite this instant but cant! so shit like!!!

Kelsey November 30, 2008 at 9:29 pm

I thought the Twi­light movie was awe­some. Although, the book was awhole lot bet­ter, they did a pretty good job con­sid­er­ing their bud­gets. I haven’t read Break­ing Dawn yet. But I have heard and read a lot of mixed com­ments on the book. Stephe­nie Meyer is a really good author, so I am hop­ing for the best.

Amber November 23, 2008 at 2:06 am

i think the 4th book was alsome and i hope they make a movie for it too

sinead November 20, 2008 at 9:54 am

omg i think break­ing dawn was the best book ever! i think it ended per­fectly and i am glad there wasnt a fight because then many of them would have to die. stephanie meyer cant please every­one, thats impos­si­ble! i love the whole twi­light series.

marie November 13, 2008 at 7:27 am

And a com­ment to the par­ent Tessa..YES, I AGREE! AS AN ADULT MYSELF (32) I HAVE TO SAY IT IS THE BEST SERIES I HAVE EVER READ!

marie November 13, 2008 at 7:24 am

Can any of you read??? For the ones who found Break­ing Dawn to be other than great, have no con­cept of the word “FANTASTIC!”

Alexander November 10, 2008 at 11:45 pm

I THINK ALL BOOKS WERE GREAT AND I THINK THERE WILL BE AOTHER BOOK BUT THIS WILL BE ABOUT NESSE AND JACOB AND ABOUT THERE LOVE LIKE BELLA AND EDWERD SO LET SEE WHAT HAPPEN ALL I KNOW THAT NEW MOON COMES TO THEARTHER 2009 SO LET SEE

Jules November 7, 2008 at 9:04 pm

I think that every­one is crazy… for say­ing they LOVED the 4th book! I am not the only who is upset by the out­come of the 4th book. And yes it is a “love story” but there was a small bat­tle in the 3rd book with Vic­to­ria and her minons. I think that if she was going to build up the fight between them, she should have at least brought their rein to an end. But hey thats just me and like 1000 other peo­ples op who aren’t affaird to call b.s. here. She didn’t know how to fin­ish the book. Lame…

Monica Cortés November 4, 2008 at 8:20 am

I think that the last book break­ing dawn was awe­some. Except for the fact that there was to much for one book. I would have to pause at every turin­ing point if you know what i mean. I still think Stephe­nie Meyer should have made a 5th book, there was too much infor­ma­tion in just one book. I just wish she wouldn’t have ended the series.=(

Paige November 2, 2008 at 9:05 pm

I would like to see all of the books made into movie and i would go see them. I liked the break­ing dawn book but i think that there should be a 5th book on my opin­ion. Also i will most defi­natly go see the movie Twilight.

JP October 29, 2008 at 3:25 pm

If there had been a big bat­tle between the Cul­lens side and the Voltari, the only way to make it feel real­is­tic would have been to kill off A LOT of the char­ac­ters (includ­ing many of the GOOD guys). How many of you would have then been com­plain­ing about that? Come on! Ms Meyer did an amaz­ing job with an incred­i­bly com­pli­cated set of cir­cum­stances. Just think how dif­fi­cult it must have been to “cover all the bases” when it came to how one power would react with another! There were so many pos­si­bil­i­ties, and I think she isn’t get­ting enough credit for mak­ing it all work.

Rach October 28, 2008 at 6:33 pm

I think any­one who didn’t like any­one of those books is abso­lut­ley crazy.All of the books are amaz​ing​.In my opin­ion twi­light is the best series ever written,and always will be.Heck yeah,Im goin to see the movie.I love Twilight!

Shannon October 24, 2008 at 11:36 am

I loved the series and I fore­see sev­eral spin­off sto­ries to come obvi­ously Jake and nessie, maybe nessie in the Amazon…I think Stephe­nie Meyer will take the story from nessie’s point of view maybe 50 years down the road or some­thing like that. Maybe then there would be a show down with the Vol­turi after Bella has had more time to learn her pow­ers full stength…

Tessa October 22, 2008 at 9:45 am

Did any­one every think that maybe in the future there could be one more book. I pur­chased Twi­light for my daugh­ter and read it my self. Then went and bought the other three. I am on my third go around of read­ing them. If you get them on CD and just lis­ten there are alot of aspects to the books that you did not real­ize are there. For the young peo­ple the books hit home about every­day life minus vam­pires and were­wolves. Par­ent prob­lems, school, dat­ing, ect. For those that did not like the end of Break­ing Dawn you have to look at the book as a love story, not as an action book. As a par­ent I think this is one of the best series I have every read.

J.D. Schuyler October 10, 2008 at 2:03 am

I am going to watch Twi­light… I have to. When your count down starts 12.12.07 and its almost time for the release of the movie, I’d say it’s a must. How­ever, I dis­liked Break­ing Dawn very much! I didn’t under­stand why she would build up a cli­max with the vol­turi… mind you for the past cou­ple of books, and then do abso­lut­ley noth­ing when it came down to the fight between them. BOO… again I scream BOO! But that’s just my opin­ion. Hey I’m sure there are peo­ple out there who hate what I write; but I promise not to end my series the same way, mak­ing every­one ques­tion­ing WHT!

Jenny September 25, 2008 at 6:18 pm

I haven’t read the whole book but I went to ama­zon and read as many excerpts as I could and I really liked it. And I think that there is some­thing wrong with the peo­ple who don’t like it.

Kayti September 8, 2008 at 11:04 am

I loved all the books. I just think that there is another story inter­twined after break­ing dawn. I have many ques­tions just-a bub­bling up in my head that it’s dri­ving me insane. I think that I will go see all the movies they make. Only because I’d like to com­pare the dif­fer­ences between the book and the movie. I also want you all to know that I have made a twi­light series fan­site that has chat and stuff like that up. If you would like to check it out go to freewebs​.com/​t​w​i​l​i​g​h​ers and yes i know there is not a t.
If you feel i should change or add some­thing i am more than wel­come to hear your thoughts. My e-mail is snickersbabyy1​9​@​aol.​com
Thanks True Twi­lighters.
–Kayti

Amber Lawliet September 1, 2008 at 3:51 pm

I loved the Break­ing Dawn book and i will def­i­nitely see the movie if at all pos­si­ble. What is it about the last book that every­body hated so much?

Renee August 27, 2008 at 3:08 pm

I will most def­i­nitely not be spend­ing my money to see this movie. I don’t expect per­fec­tion from authors. No author is ever going to sat­isfy every­one, but Break­ing Dawn was a dis­ap­point­ment beyond mea­sure!! I just hope Stephe­nie will go back to rais­ing her kids and leave the lit­er­ary world alone.

kaitlyn August 19, 2008 at 3:27 pm

I did like what hap­pened in break­ing dawn… i just didnt like HOW it hap­pened. I am a fan.

vianess August 18, 2008 at 9:19 pm

first of all i love break­ing dawn!!!!! it was really great from my point of view!!! (per­sonal opin­ion ok??)
and even if i didnt like it i dont under­stand why should this inter­fer with twi­light movie??? per­son­aly think the ones that are chang­ing def. their point of view just because the series didnt end as they want to.…. those are not fans, and think they really never liked twilight.

kaitlyn August 18, 2008 at 8:35 pm

It will come out on Novem­ber 21, 2008… Harry Pot­ter was pushed back till sum­mer 09 so Twi­light took their spot.

liana August 18, 2008 at 6:42 pm

is the movie twi­light com­ing out on Novem­ber the 21st like stephe­nie mey­ers offi­cial web­site says or decem­ber the 12th ?

Chloza August 15, 2008 at 5:57 am

Well, straight after read­ing Break­ing Dawn, I couldn’t even think about the Twlight movie, let alone look at the actors. I couldn’t even imag­ine read­ing any of the books again.

Now I’m in my lit­tle world of denial, I can think about the movie. I might see it, it looks promis­ing to me. I’ll just pre­tend there was no Break­ing Dawn. I love the cast, and I know they can help rekin­dle my fandom.

But I don’t want to see BD made into a film. No way.

Kaitlyn August 14, 2008 at 6:03 pm

I will def­i­nitely be going to see Twi­light. There were many moments in the first three books that I would enjoy see­ing brought to film. I am very curi­ous how they are going to change the boys into Were­wolves… If they do make a movie for Break­ing Dawn, I will most likely go see it. I am def­i­nitely in sup­port of the cast, and love the chem­istry they all have so far, and if the cast con­tin­ues to do well, then I will sup­port them by going to see the Break­ing Dawn movie(s).

bookcollector August 7, 2008 at 10:54 am

I will admit that the con­clu­sion of the Twi­light saga left me want­ing, but i don’t think that Break­ing Dawn has ruined the movie-adaptation of Twi­light. i like to enjoy what i have, and i think the film of Twi­light will have a suf­f­i­cent resem­b­lence of what the orig­i­nal book was. How­ever, there is no way in the world that i would ven­ture to see another Twilight-related film. If the pro­duc­ers announced that they were going to film any of the other books, ESPECIALLY Break­ing Dawn, they’d hear noth­ing but “hatemail” from me.

tcalo August 7, 2008 at 5:37 am

I am dis­a­pointed with the book, but I think I will go to see the movie, after all I did like twi­light. Though I don’t think they are going to make a movie of break­ing dawn, and if they do I will not goint to see that.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: