REVIEW: ‘Kin (The Good Neighbors)’ by Holly Black and Illustrated by Ted Naifeh

by Avid Reader on September 18, 2008

in Book Reviews, Fantasy, Grade B Reviews, Graphic Novels

Kin (The Good Neighbors):Book One writ­ten by Holly Black and Illus­trated by Ted Naifeh (2008).

Holly Black, the author of YA fan­tasy nov­els such as Tithe and Iron­side, pens her first graphic novel about what else, faeries. Sur­prised? I was. I didn’t real­ize this was a graphic novel.

Rue Silver’s mother, Nia, is a faerie. She fell in love with a mor­tal who made a pact with her father for her hand in mar­riage. That promise gets bro­ken and her mother is whisked back to the faerie realm.

Rue’s mother has been miss­ing for more than 3 weeks and her father, Thad­deus, doesn’t seem to be wor­ried about her. He hasn’t reported her miss­ing and he hasn’t been going to work. He just sits and stares at nothing.

Thad­deus is a col­lege pro­fes­sor who teaches Folk­lore at Ben­ton Col­lege. A col­league of his, Amanda Valia, has been cov­er­ing for him. It seems that Thad­deus and his faerie wife were hav­ing mar­i­tal trou­ble. Rue over­hears them argu­ing one night and that’s the last time she has seen her.

Aside from her mother’s dis­ap­pear­ance, Rue begins to see the world around her with dif­fer­ent eyes. The well hid­den, super­nat­ural com­mu­nity around her begins to reveal itself and this makes her think that she’s los­ing her mind. She sees shapes hid­den in shad­ows, strangers who know her name and winged faeries star­ing back at her. What’s going on?

To com­pli­cate mat­ters, her house is raided by the police one night when she’s out with friends. They have arrested her father for the mur­der of a col­lege stu­dent. It doesn’t look good for him since her mother’s been miss­ing for more than 3 weeks. So the police sus­pect foul play and take him into custody.

Much of the story is spent with Rue inves­ti­gat­ing her mother’s dis­ap­pear­ance and doing a lit­tle detec­tive work to prove that her father is inno­cent. Her friends chip in and help. The story gets inter­est­ing when she meets her mother’s fam­ily for the first time. Her faerie grand­fa­ther Aubrey, along with his assis­tant, Tam, have filed a tem­po­rary cus­tody order for Rue to live with him but she rebuffs the offer.

Aubrey is not exactly a nice man and he has a men­ac­ing air about him. Aubrey con­firms much of what Rue sus­pects about her birthright and demands that she makes a choice. He gives her a quick his­tory of the rela­tion­ship between humans and faeries or as they call them­selves, “the good neigh­bors.” Faeries at one time were con­sid­ered a peace­ful peo­ple that humans once feared and as Aubrey tells Rue, “they shall fear” again. Omi­nous words of what is to come for unsus­pect­ing humans.

At the heart of this story, it is about a daugh­ter search­ing for her mother and learn­ing about her true her­itage. It’s a novel about loy­alty and self-discovery. The story is some­what dark and pop­u­lated with strange faerie folk who seem some­what friendly but dangerous.

I enjoyed this graphic novel espe­cially since it uti­lizes much of Holly Black’s strengths. She is really good at con­trast­ing super­nat­ural ele­ments with that of mod­ern real­ity. It’s one of the rea­sons why I will always seek out her work. If you’re already famil­iar with her darker, fan­tasy nov­els for teens, you can expect more of the same here, with­out a lot of dark under­tones and violence.

This is a decent first effort in my opin­ion but then I’m a ama­teur reader in this genre. The art­work has to grow on you but oth­er­wise, I’d rate this a B. Kin The Good Neigh­bors, Book One man­aged to ful­fill my expec­ta­tions. I’m hop­ing book two will ele­vate this series to a higher level of sto­ry­telling that Black is known for. It will be inter­est­ing to see how many of Holly Black’s fans will embrace this for­mat. I think it’s worth a look. B.

For Fur­ther Reading

{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }

vanessa jaye September 18, 2008 at 4:46 pm

This sounds/looks inter­est­ing. Thanks for the heads up on it, Keishon.

ReplyReply
Kailana September 18, 2008 at 6:17 am

I would be more likely to start this series by her than fin­ish the other one! Thanks for bring­ing it to my atten­tion, I had net even heard any­thing about it.

ReplyReply

Leave a Comment

Please leave these two fields as-is:

Protected by Invisible Defender. Showed 403 to 838 bad guys.

Previous post:

Next post: