Reviews Of Two Noteworthy Graphic Novel(s)

by Avid Reader on August 17, 2009

in Book Reviews, Grade B Reviews, Graphic Novels, Teen Fiction

Might have to go back to post­ing graphic novel reviews on Mon­days. I’ve col­lected a ton of them this year. And yes, I am still col­lect­ing them. When you delve into this genre, it can be a bit over­whelm­ing. But there are good resources out there to help you cut through the crap and get to the good stuff.

And I only read the good stuff, folks. Here we go.

Oshinbo coverOish­inbo: Japan­ese Cui­sine (vol.1) story by Tetsu Kariya and art by Akira Hanasaki & pub­lished by Viz Media. Oish­inbo grabbed my atten­tion for two rea­sons: the back blurb that states that Oish­inbo has […over 100 mil­lion copies sold world­wide…] and the sub­ject mat­ter revolves around Japan’s culi­nary culture.

While food is the pri­mary focus, there’s an ongo­ing story arc that revolves around the rivalry between father and son. Yes, I love good drama. Kaibara Yuzan is a huge bear of a man who has a pas­sion for food and a very short tem­per. He is a very demand­ing man. He’s the founder of the highly respected and hard to get into restau­rant, The Gourmet Club. Kaibara doesn’t get along with his son, Yamaoka Shiro, who’s a jour­nal­ist for the Tozai News.

Father and son rela­tion­ship is very strained. Yamaoka blames his father for his mother’s early demise since she had to bear the brunt of his father’s wrath for cook­ing him mediocre meals + other things. Kaibara has a nasty habit of mak­ing peo­ple redo his meals until they get it right. He’s Japan’s equiv­a­lent of Gor­don Ram­sey. Par­tially jok­ing on that last part.

Yamaoka believes that his father’s love for food was more impor­tant than his fam­ily. So he lashes out and as a result, he has been unwel­come in his father’s home ever since the “inci­dent.” At work, Yamaoka has been given an impor­tant assign­ment: to research the Ulti­mate Menu along­side his co-workers at Tozai News for their 100th Anniver­sary. While Yamakoza doesn’t share his father’s deep love for art and food, he’s skilled in the kitchen. Most peo­ple tend to think he’s lazy but he shows them differently.

Aside from the father/son rela­tion­ship, the sto­ries are bro­ken down by “ten courses” where each one expounds on what makes Japan­ese cui­sine cul­tur­ally sig­nif­i­cant. You have tech­nique, ingre­di­ents, pre­sen­ta­tion, fla­vor + other things that must all come together to make for a mem­o­rable meal. But all of those things are mean­ing­less if it doesn’t come from the heart.

I enjoyed this manga because it is very engag­ing and very infor­ma­tive! I’m not a big culi­nary fan out­side of con­sump­tion but this is one manga that I read quickly and was smart enough to have on hand, the sec­ond to read for tonight until I get my hands on more. This is a char­ac­ter dri­ven story but it’s the food and the tech­niques that make this manga a huge winner.

Viz Media seems to be reis­su­ing Oish­inbo under their sig­na­ture line and are com­pil­ing them into groups with the same sub­ject mat­ter. The author also pro­vides insight into his def­i­n­i­tion of Japan­ese cui­sine and the novel has sec­tion for notes where you can find def­i­n­i­tions and the like for pan­els that need addi­tional explain­ing. Oish­inbo was a great find and a great read. B+.

Note: This book reads from right to left and is rated T for Teens. Price is $12.99 USA.

*****

Ikigami: The Ulti­mate Limit (vol. 1,2) story & art by Motoro Mase. Pub­lished by VizMedia.

Ikigami coverI don’t go out of my way to find depres­sive sto­ries but find this one I did. I read a review of where Ikigami was favor­ably com­pared to another GN I read, Death­note. In “Ikigami,” the story fea­tures a dystopian soci­ety where under gov­ern­ment rule, peo­ple are being forced to “value life.” Let me explain.

The National Wel­fare Act is a law that “pre­serves the wel­fare of the peo­ple” where “obe­di­ence is the key to hap­pi­ness.” For the past nine years, the gov­ern­ment has been giv­ing chil­dren immu­niza­tion shots that fights off dis­ease and con­tains a nanocap­sule that trav­els and resides in the pul­monary artery. The cap­sule is timed to explode on a given day, time and year when they are between the ages of 18 and 24.

The sys­tem is overly com­plex to ensure secrecy and the chances of get­ting the nanocap­sule is 1:1000 or 0.01% of the pop­u­la­tion. The sys­tem is also set up to pro­vide fam­i­lies of the deceased with bereave­ment com­pen­sa­tion and that’s only pro­vided if the cit­i­zen doesn’t act out or cause havoc before their impend­ing death.

Each child enter­ing ele­men­tary school gets the shot and are told that some of them will not live past adult­hood. Stu­dents are taught that their death is for the good of the coun­try. The gov­ern­ment thinks that the fear of death will instill val­ues into a soci­ety that was once crime rid­den and sedentary.

The Wel­fare Act claims suc­cess with these new laws, cit­ing low crime rates and higher pro­duc­tiv­ity. Dis­senters of this pro­gram are either brain­washed to fol­low along or they are given the shot with the nanocap­sule to silence their rhetoric.

The heavy bur­den of inform­ing some­one of their impend­ing death is given to Fuji­moto. He works at the Civil Reg­is­tra­tion Sec­tion of the ward office and has been on the job for a few months. As the mes­sen­ger, he deliv­ers the “Ikigami” aka “death papers” to the cit­i­zens whose death is immi­nent within 24 hours.

The sto­ries in Ikigami closely exam­ine these cit­i­zens in their last 24 hours. When noti­fied, they are imme­di­ately given access to resources and are waived cer­tain expenses, fees and such in their final hours. We watch them strug­gle to absorb the news and reflect on what they’ve done with their lives and see­ing what deci­sions they make in their final hours.

The sto­ries are cap­ti­vat­ing and you just never knew who would get the “ikigami” paper when each story began. While we fol­low every­day cit­i­zens who have been given these let­ters, it is Fugimoto’s strug­gle with the respon­si­bil­i­ties of his job along with the emo­tional bur­den, as he puts it, in crush­ing people’s hopes and dreams, that is the focal point.

If you were given only 24 hours left to live, what would you do with your time? That’s essen­tially what this series addresses along with the usual themes of hope, liv­ing life to the fullest and liv­ing each day as if it was your last. I’ve read the first two vol­umes in this series thus far and so far, so good.

Art­work and pan­els are easy to fol­low and the manga reads from right to left and is again, pub­lished by Viz Media. They seem to be putting out some good stuff lately. Unsure if I want to con­tinue to fol­low this series but I am curi­ous to know if Fugi­moto, who sur­vives to adult­hood unlike oth­ers, will con­tinue to do this line of work or will he resign? What story or assign­ment will move him to rebel against the sys­tem? Grade for vol 1 & 2: B. The next issue is due out in Novem­ber.

Note: This book is rated M for Mature audi­ences, price is $12.99 USA.

For Fur­ther Reading

Leave a Comment

Please leave these two fields as-is:

Protected by Invisible Defender. Showed 403 to 877 bad guys.

Previous post:

Next post: