Underwhelmed with “Children of the Sea” by Daisuke Igarashi

by Avid Reader on September 21, 2009 · 0 comments Tagged as:

in Book Reviews, Grade C Reviews, Graphic Novels

children of the seaChil­dren of the Sea (vol.1) by Daisuke Igarashi and pub­lished by Viz Media, US $14.99, 320 pgs. Rated T for older teens.

“There are demons in the sea.”

What can I say, the cover was arrest­ing and the story sounded promis­ing but after read­ing this graphic novel I was left.. under­whelmed. I would add on baf­fle­ment and utter bore­dom, too.

The story alludes that there are chil­dren who live in the sea. The first encounter of this comes from a under­wa­ter cam­era­man in the Philip­pines who declares that there are “demons” who live in the sea. Then Ruka, the story’s nar­ra­tor, sees what she calls a “ghost” in the aquar­ium where her dad works. The “ghost of the sea” as she terms it, is fully illu­mi­nated before it disappears.

Ruka is a tomboy. She loves to play hand­ball but gets kicked off the team due to a scuf­fle with her team­mate. Dis­ap­pointed and hurt with noth­ing to do, she ends up befriend­ing a young boy name Umi. Umi is dif­fer­ent. Umi along with his brother Sora, were raised in the ocean.

Mean­while, the mys­tery of the ocean takes cen­ter stage. I guess that’s the best part of the story is the ocean’s vast­ness and mys­tery. I mean, how many humans do you know of who were raised in the sea? Umi is not a mer­maid. He is human but suf­fers from dry skin. He and his brother can’t stay out of the water for long peri­ods of time so they wear long robes to pro­tect their skin. That’s because their bod­ies have adapted to the ocean.

Sorry to say but “Chil­dren of the Sea” was under­whelm­ing. I kept read­ing and read­ing hop­ing to finally get hooked but alas, that didn’t hap­pen until after more than a few chap­ters in. New story + slow build-up didn’t work for me. Every­thing was just so bizarre and I can’t go on read­ing stuff that doesn’t explain itself within a rea­son­able amount of time. Am hes­i­tant to read more because the plot is slow going.

There are lit­tle seg­ments here or there that are sup­posed to be seen as “true accounts” or “tes­ti­monies” from three peo­ple who’ve wit­nessed weird phe­nom­ena. I was espe­cially moved by the story about a lit­tle boy who shows up to help out some fish­er­man on the har­bor. The boy’s strength and hard work makes him mem­o­rable but what really stood out was that the fish­er­man didn’t think the kid acted “nor­mal.” Sure enough his the­ory or sus­pi­cions are proven true from the boy’s phys­i­cal appearance.

All I have to say is inter­est­ing con­cept, start of the story set the eerie tone or mood just right and the art­work was fan­tas­tic but I was left under­whelmed by the story over­all. The novel opens with about 9 pages of color. Truly beau­ti­ful work. This is a story that is some of shades of famil­iar, about kids who are out­siders who are caught up in an impor­tant search for the “ghost of the sea.”

If you enjoy sto­ries about myths and leg­ends or enjoy mys­ter­ies of the unknown, you may want to give Chil­dren of the Sea a try. C. But you have to be patient for the story to take off, though. Chil­dren of the Sea has been reviewed here as well if you want a more pos­i­tive take on the story.

For Fur­ther Reading

Leave a Comment

Please leave these two fields as-is:

Protected by Invisible Defender. Showed 403 to 694 bad guys.

Previous post:

Next post: